“What I would like to do is to leave behind a sustainable entity of a set of companies that operate in an exemplary manner in terms of ethics, values and continue what our ancestors left behind.” Ratan Naval Tata

On 9th October 2024, at exactly 11.30 pm IST,  the towering 5 feet 10 inches tall Surat born Parsee industrialist-philanthropist Padma Vibhushan Ratan (meaning “precious jewel”) Naval Tata, the Chairman Emeritus and the patriarch of the House of Tata, the largest business conglomerate in India (having a staggering annual revenue of over 165 billion US Dollars and encompassing a grand well knit family of over 1 million happy, well cared for and dedicated members worldwide!), breathed his last at the iconic Beach Candy Hospital nestled atop the Arabian Sea facing Cumballa Hill (popularly called “Diplomat’s Hill” or “Ambassador’s Row” and home to the most prominent billionaires in Mumbai, including my old friend Mukesh Ambani) at the age of 86.  He was hospitalised on 7th October, 2024 owing to a critical combination of senescence and hypotension. It was in the very same hospital that my very dear titanic friend and sincere well-wisher Dhirajlal “Dhirubhai” Hirachand Ambani passed away way back on 7th July 2002. At the time of his death, Ratan held a 0.83 percent stake in Tata Sons and had a net worth of Rs 7,900 crores. A large part of his wealth—nearly 75 percent—was tied to his shares in Tata Sons. For Ratan, accolades poured in from across the country and from all corners of the world in a torrential stream. In an impassioned eulogy that reflected the melancholy mood of a shattered nation, our Prime Minister Narendra Modi tweeted - “Shri Ratan Tata was a visionary business leader, a compassionate soul, and an extraordinary human being. He provided stable leadership to one of India’s oldest and most prestigious business houses. At the same time, his contribution went beyond the boardroom. He endeared himself to several people thanks to his humility, kindness and an unwavering commitment to making our society better.”

On 10th October 2024, Eric Garcetti, the US Ambassador to India, lamented the death of the former architecture and structural engineering graduate from the Cornell University College of Architecture, University of California (in 2008, Ratan gifted Cornell University $50 million, becoming the largest international donor in the university’s history!) and the graduate in architecture from the University of California, Berkeley (named after George Berkeley, the distinguished Anglo-Irish philosopher, known as “Bishop Berkeley”, and in collaboration with which Ratan set up the UC-RNT Fund primarily to back Indian startups) who had completed the Advanced Management Program at Harvard Business School, “He was one of those people whose vision was as limitless as the horizon, who helped show what was possible in India and what was possible in the world.” On 13th October 2024, the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin “Bibi” Netanyahu condoled Ratan’s death and highlighted his immense contributions to foster Israel-India ties, “I and many in Israel mourn the loss of Ratan Tata, a proud son of India and a champion of the friendship between our two countries.” On 14th October 2024, Padma Bhushan Natarajan Chandrasekaran, (popularly known as “Chandra”), the most worthy successor of Ratan (he effortlessly stepped into Ratan’s distinguished shoes and proudly donned his enviable mantle on 12th January 2017!) and my personal friend for over 15 years since my heady days as a long term Advisor to Tata Consultancy Services Ltd. (“TCS”), the flagship of the prodigious Tata fleet, paid an effusive heartfelt homage to his former boss and mentor, “Anybody who met Mr. Tata came away with a story about his humanity, warmth, and dreams for India. There was no one like him.” 

Joseph Bitner Wirthlin, the renowned American businessman and religious leader rightly observed, “Some memories are unforgettable, remaining ever vivid and heartwarming!” In a moment of helpless nostalgia, my mind goes back irresistibly to the rather sultry summer day in the year 1986 when I fortuitously met Ratan (he was then the Chairman of Tata Industries and had in that capacity drafted the Tata Strategic Plan) for the very first time within the majestic confines of the Taj Palace Hotel, the only “palace” hotel in the national capital since 1983. I briefly introduced myself to Ratan telling him four distinct facets about myself : (a) I was a limb of the law and my senior and guru was Asoke Kumar Sen (“Asoke Mamu”), the then Union Law Minister in the Cabinet of my charismatic friend Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi (“Rajiv Bhai”), and the undisputed leader of the Indian Bar; (b) the two topmost Parsee lawyers of the country viz. Nanabhoy “Nani” Ardeshir Palkhivala, one of the inextricable doyens of the House of Tata, and Uncle Fali, were not only close to me and Asoke Mamu but were my professional heroes and role-models; (c) I was a close friend and fervent associate of  “PV” Narasimha Rao, the then Union Minister of Home Affairs, who was my steadfast mentor and father figure (“Uncle PV”); and (d) I had a close association with Tata Steel and in particular with Russi Mody, its effervescent foodaholic Chairman & Managing Director, whom I had introduced to Uncle PV and who had scrupulously mulled the idea of using my voice for a documentary film entitled “Tata Steel - Challenge of the 80s” as the narrator because he felt (in all seriousness!) that I possessed a “Voice of Steel”. Ratan looked visibly impressed and disclosed to me that he had indeed seen the film on Tata Steel on one of his numerous visits to Jamshedpur.

Ratan often stayed at a modest guest house in the Tata Apartments at 23, Prithviraj Road, New Delhi. During those vibrant days, Uncle PV, residing at 9, Motilal Nehru Marg, frequently visited the iconic coffee shop Machan in Taj Mansingh Hotel. There, he would catch up with friends like me over endless cups of freshly brewed, sugar-free filter coffee, accompanied by steamed idlis and vadas soaked in mild sambar. If Ratan happened to be at the hotel during these visits, he never missed the opportunity to greet Uncle PV, whom he deeply admired. After Uncle PV assumed the role of Prime Minister on 21 June, 1991, following the tragic assassination of Rajiv Bhai on 21 May 1991, but before moving into the official residence at 7, Race Course Road (now Lok Kalyan Marg), a special suite was arranged for his family and close associates at the Taj Mansingh Hotel. This arrangement, facilitated through Ratan's efforts, ensured the comfort and security of Uncle PV's family. The suite was guarded round the clock by the Special Protection Group (SPG), and Ratan personally oversaw their well-being during their stay. I had the extraordinary privilege of staying with Uncle PV at his residence even before he became the Prime Minister, a position that would later redefine the country's destiny. As a frequent visitor to the Taj Mansingh suite, I often interacted with Uncle PV’s sons, Rajeshwar and Prabhakar, under the vigilant watch of SPG personnel. It was there that I first met one of my close friend Prashant Tewari, who worked closely with Uncle PV and Hansraj Bhardwaj, co-ordinating key developments during that pivotal period. Ratan, as always, proved to be a gracious and hospitable host throughout these memorable interactions.

On 26th November, 2008, “a date which will live in infamy”, Mumbai, the financial capital of India, witnessed a brutal, dastardly terrorist attack orchestrated by the Pakistani sponsored group Lashkar-e-Taiba, when the Indian Home Secretary Madukar Gupta, by an ominous coincidence, was enjoying Pakistan’s hospitality in Murree, a mountain resort city close to Islamabad. Ten highly trained and heavily armed terrorists infiltrated the city, having stealthily landed in inflatable speed boats at Macchimar Nagar, in Mumbai's Cuffe Parade neighbourhood, and heinously targeted several meticulously planned locations, including the Taj Mahal Palace.  The Indian Government’s response to the attack was “pusillanimous”, as aptly observed by the Hindustan Times on 26th November, 2023! Lamentably, the UPA Government was being led by a weak, diffident, rudderless and indecisive Prime Minister Manmohan Singh (who had blamed his mentor Uncle PV for the massacre of Sikhs in 1984 without a shred of evidence and had done precious little to bring the perpetrators of the genocide to book or alleviate the suffering of the victims, particularly widows!), reminiscent of Sir Arthur  Neville Chamberlain at the outbreak of the Second World War. The attack claimed 166 lives, including 33 at the Taj Mahal Palace, and did not spare even the General Manager of the hotel Karambir Singh Kang’s wife Niti and his two young teenage sons Uday and Samar. Gautam Shantilal Adani, the Indian billionaire businessman (who has recently been in the eye of a storm!), by a superb stroke of luck, managed to save himself by hiding in the kitchen of the hotel! Defying all odds, it was Ratan who in a truly Churchillian manner valiantly rose to the occasion and provided the much-needed leadership to an embattled nation facing an “ordeal of the most grievous kind”! In the face of the attack watched by a shell-shocked nation, Ratan, who was then 70, displayed superhuman courage, resolve and determination. He strode like a colossus and stood like the Rock of Gibraltar at the Colaba end of the Taj Mahal Palace for 3 days, as security forces fiercely battled the terrorists in the Taj Mahal Palace. Everyone became just those inches taller, every back just that much broader, as Ratan’s own was. This was undoubtedly Ratan’s finest hour when he embodied the will, spirit and grit of our people..indomitable, undaunted, relentless!

I have a myriad of friends who knew Ratan intimately and worked with him closely. All of them are unquestionably ad idem about Ratan: “He was a genuinely good, dedicated and large-hearted soul filled with the milk of human kindness and  our age is hardly fit to understand him.” At the same time, I can assert, without mincing words, that there are many unscrupulous men and women, including foreign nationals, who conveniently basked in the warmth of Ratan’s sunshine, recklessly flaunted, dropped or exploited his name for personal gain and private considerations in India and even beyond its frontiers and promoted, projected and publicised themselves by misusing his name thereby bringing unspeakable disgrace, dishonour and discredit to Ratan and the House of Tata. It is heartening to note that Chandra has managed to astutely keep at bay all such persons in the best interests of the House of Tata!

Be that as it may, we should remember the stellar quality of Ratan’s character as well as the remarkable range of his achievements. In his love of adventure and his imaginative powers, he was far removed from the modern industrialist-philanthropist. Yet everyone who came in contact with him paid tribute to the unimaginable power of his mind. He had an aptitude for business which raised him far above the ordinary levels of our generation. He had a firmness of spirit that was not often elated by success, seldom downcast by failure and never swayed by panic.  He loved life and was perfectly at peace with himself and the world around him. He could be helplessly uproarious. He wanted everyone to be happy. He wanted to taste and try everything that life could offer. Power never corrupted him, nor did success make him conceited, arrogant, or pompous. Beyond his reputation as a business magnate and animal lover, Ratan’s tenure as Chairman of the Tata Trusts has left an inerasable mark on India’s cultural kaleidoscope. The trusts have spearheaded numerous initiatives across healthcare, education, environment and disaster relief and their manifold contributions to art and culture stand out as particularly noteworthy. With no thought of the length of time he might be permitted on Planet Earth, Ratan was concerned solely with the quality of the service he could render to his nation and humanity.

I cannot do better than conclude with Modi’s emotional tribute in the press and media on 9th November 2024:

“As we remember him today, we are reminded of the society he envisioned—where business can serve as a force for good, where every individual’s potential is valued and where progress is measured in the well-being and happiness of all. He remains alive in the lives he touched and the dreams he nurtured. Generations will be grateful to him for making India a better, kinder and more hopeful place.”

The author is an internationally reputed senior lawyer practicing in the Supreme Court of India and various High Courts and Tribunals in India.

The cooperative model, rooted in mutual collaboration and community-centric development, has played a pivotal role in shaping the socio-economic landscape of India. As the country navigates challenges of economic inequality, rural underdevelopment, and employment creation, cooperatives offer a sustainable framework to empower communities and promote inclusive growth. This article explores the evolution of the cooperative model, its future opportunities, policy advancements, technological integration, and how it is poised to transform India’s rural economy.

The cooperative movement in India began during the colonial era, primarily to address agrarian distress. The Cooperative Societies Act of 1904 marked the formal establishment of this framework, enabling credit cooperatives to tackle usurious lending practices. Post-independence, cooperatives became integral to India’s Five-Year Plans, especially in sectors like agriculture, dairy, and small-scale industries.

The success of initiatives like the White Revolution, driven by dairy cooperatives under the leadership of the National Dairy Development Board (NDDB) and institutions like Amul, showcased the transformative potential of the cooperative model. Over the decades, the scope of cooperatives expanded to include housing, labor, fisheries, handlooms, and banking. Today, India boasts over 8 lakh cooperative societies, contributing significantly to rural employment, agricultural output, and financial inclusion. However, challenges like lack of professionalism, limited technological adoption, and bureaucratic inefficiencies continue to impede their full potential.

Future Opportunities in the Cooperative Sector
The cooperative model holds immense promise in fostering economic equality and social welfare. Some of the key opportunities include:

1. Agri-Tech and Value-Added Farming
Cooperatives can serve as conduits for farmers to adopt agri-tech solutions like precision farming, soil health monitoring, and smart irrigation. By pooling resources, small and marginal farmers can invest in technology and access high-value markets, boosting productivity and profitability.

2. Strengthening Farmer Producer Organizations (FPOs)
With government support, cooperatives can evolve into robust Farmer Producer Organizations (FPOs), helping farmers collectively procure inputs, access credit, and sell produce at competitive prices. This will reduce exploitation by intermediaries and increase farmer incomes.

3. Renewable Energy Cooperatives
The renewable energy sector, particularly solar and biomass energy, offers lucrative opportunities for cooperatives. By setting up community-owned energy projects, rural areas can achieve energy self-sufficiency while creating local employment.

4. Women-Led Cooperatives
Women’s participation in cooperatives can be a game-changer, especially in sectors like self-help groups (SHGs), crafts, and dairy. Empowering women through cooperatives will not only enhance household incomes but also contribute to broader social equity.

5. Export-Oriented Initiatives
With adequate policy support, cooperatives can tap into international markets, especially for organic produce, handicrafts, and textiles. Branding and marketing initiatives can help rural producers gain global recognition.

Policy and Collaborative Ecosystem
A supportive policy environment is critical for the cooperative sector's growth. Key areas of focus include:

1. Legal and Institutional Reforms
Modernizing the legal framework governing cooperatives is essential to ensure transparency, accountability, and efficiency. The recently established Ministry of Cooperation aims to streamline policy interventions and bolster the sector's capabilities.

2. Credit and Financial Inclusion
Access to affordable credit remains a challenge for many cooperatives. Policies must prioritize cooperative banks and microfinance institutions to ensure liquidity and financial support for rural enterprises.

3. Collaborative Public-Private Models
Public-private partnerships (PPPs) can bring much-needed expertise, innovation, and capital to cooperatives. Corporates can collaborate with cooperatives under their CSR initiatives to develop skills, technology, and market linkages.

4. Capacity Building and Training
Skill development and leadership training for cooperative members and leaders can foster professionalism. Collaborations with educational institutions and NGOs can help in building a strong knowledge base.

5. Digital Integration
The government’s push for a Digital India can be leveraged to digitize cooperative operations, ensuring transparency, real-time monitoring, and access to e-markets.

Technological Integration: The Game-Changer
The integration of technology in cooperatives is pivotal for their modernization and efficiency. Some promising technological avenues include:

1. Digital Platforms for Market Linkages
E-commerce platforms can connect rural producers directly with consumers, eliminating middlemen and ensuring fair prices. Platforms like eNAM (National Agriculture Market) can be further strengthened for cooperative participation.

2. Blockchain for Transparency
Blockchain technology can be used to maintain transparent records of transactions, inventory, and member contributions, ensuring trust and accountability within cooperatives.

3. Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Agriculture
AI-powered tools for weather prediction, pest control, and crop management can help cooperatives optimize agricultural output.

4. Mobile Banking and Digital Payments
Mobile-based financial services can enhance the operational efficiency of cooperative banks, making financial transactions seamless for rural members.

5. Data Analytics for Decision-Making
Data-driven insights can guide cooperatives in resource allocation, market trends, and demand forecasting, improving their competitiveness.

Transforming the Indian Rural Economy
The cooperative model is uniquely positioned to address the multifaceted challenges of India’s rural economy. Its potential impacts include:

1. Employment Generation
By organizing local resources and creating value chains, cooperatives can generate sustainable employment opportunities in rural areas, reducing migration to urban centers.

2. Enhancing Agricultural Productivity
Through collective farming, access to modern technology, and better supply chain management, cooperatives can significantly boost agricultural productivity and rural incomes.

3. Financial Inclusion
Cooperative banks and credit societies play a crucial role in providing affordable credit to underserved rural populations, fostering entrepreneurial activities.

4. Empowerment of Marginalized Groups
Cooperatives create a platform for marginalized communities, including women and tribal populations, to participate in economic activities, enhancing their social and economic status.

5. Promoting Sustainable Development
From renewable energy projects to organic farming, cooperatives can champion sustainable practices, contributing to environmental conservation and climate resilience.

Roadmap Ahead
The roadmap for strengthening India’s cooperative sector involves a multi-pronged approach:

Policy Push: Implementing targeted policies to modernize the legal and financial frameworks of cooperatives.
Capacity Building: Fostering leadership and management skills within cooperatives to drive innovation and growth.
Tech-Driven Solutions: Leveraging digital tools to enhance operational efficiency, transparency, and market access.
Collaborative Models: Encouraging partnerships with corporates, NGOs, and international agencies for knowledge-sharing and investment.
Monitoring and Accountability: Establishing mechanisms to ensure accountability, minimize corruption, and promote good governance in cooperative societies.

Conclusion
The rise of the cooperative economic framework represents a paradigm shift in how India approaches inclusive development. By empowering communities, promoting equitable resource distribution, and leveraging technology, cooperatives can bridge the rural-urban divide and drive sustainable growth. As India aspires to become a $5 trillion economy, strengthening the cooperative model will not only uplift millions of rural livelihoods but also reinforce the nation’s commitment to self-reliance and shared prosperity. The future of India’s rural economy lies in the power of collective effort—where every hand contributes, and every hand benefits.

Standing tall, with a simple elegant dress, an unforgettably graceful smile and his presence well felt by millions at various moments, is a sheer contrast to the business outlook of Shri Ratan Tata. It wouldn’t be wrong if I call him an able successor to the “Father of Indian Industries” who left us with a big void yet a life full of lessons that are testimonials for the current and coming generations. For all those who followed him, were inspired and influenced by him, who are now feeling hopeless, not knowing the way forward; we must understand that Shri Ratan Tata continues to live a life of ethics and philosophies in our lives that’s etched in our memories for time immemorial. From the morning tea you sip, the car you move around with, the steel bars and railings you hold, the schools your children go to, the insurance that you pay bills, and the coffee meeting you hold, there are moments in every step that you take that reminds you that Tata is a legacy to thank and beyond. While his established group of companies and organizations follow the “Tata Culture” to the core, the newer ones are far from emulating the same approach. The man behind the largest industrial set-up in India, a bigger international deal maker and a humble man next door has been easily approachable and accessible to not just the Business community but also young innovative minds.

Tata Culture- imbibes core values in terms of “Building Trust & Relationship” to the extent that the term ‘Tata’ is synonymous to “trust”, only if the lexicographers wish to add this term today to the dictionary. Humanity, Employee benefits & safety, transparency in business, Ethical Leadership, Empathy towards the poor and the animals alike etc., have been well established across various verticals in the Tata world. Tata Trusts- better exhibits these value systems by contributing to education, healthcare, and technology startups. The trusts (2014) - perhaps a method to enable contributions to various sectors whilst continuing his business successes. Knowing his philanthropical DNA, this also may have been his rendezvous to connect with the needy community in the country.

The stories and memes gushing through the internet since his absence from the quintessential Bollywood star Amitabh Bachchan to a humble professor at IISc who was spearheading the faculty entrepreneurship while Mr. Ratan Tata was the President of the Court of IISc; are substantial proof of this visionary entrepreneur as an innovative adventurer and a go-to friend when in need. One can only wonder about the reasons behind his industrious life goals, Beautiful Mind, thoughtful leadership, humble life and sincerity in every word and commitment in every walk. He’s established it very well that life is not a bed of roses but with thorns, and one must be courageous to handle the ordeal even if it means contradicting the world’s best; recollecting the launch of Tata Indica, was or is it a failure to recon even today? Let’s take Nano Car for example- a project that no one could believe was a possibility, the Ford that once refused to shake hands with Mr. Tata but as the name goes Endeavour belongs here with the Tata as remarkable a conquest as Everest, followed by Starbucks who never felt the need for its presence in India is now the landmark FNB joint across the country. There are many such ventures which Mr. Tata risked himself to go beyond boundaries and expressed the audacity of how a simple thought can manifest into larger achievement- Jaguar Land Rover, Corus Steel, Tata Tea- Tetley etc are a few names in this category. It could be sheer patriotism, resilience, or business astute who looks at the world as a large playground to be the heroic player.

While he has bagged the best of awards for his exemplary achievements in the past, he never stopped there; instead, he continued to keep an open mind to engage with the young minds, their innovations, and their creativity and opened doors for newer ideas to evolve- his investments in tech start-ups like Ola & Paytm were historic in the investor’s domain. How can one forget the MotoPaws Story- when Shantanu Naidu devised an idea to save dogs from being hit by speeding vehicles at night? He made reflective collars and invested his money to start the initiative. A video of dogs wearing reflective collars in Pune went viral on the internet. When Ratan Tata, who is a passionate dog lover, came across this initiative through a video and he immediately arranged a meeting with Shantanu. The rest is history.

There could be volumes of information that’s today accessible by everyone and there are a few chapters that speak about his intimate relations with old and new colleagues alike, this marks the humility and learner’s mind beyond a businessman title that he has adorned for decades. His life is as a child, adult, entrepreneur, leading businessman, negotiator, a deal maker etc., each is a story in itself with lots of ideologies, philosophies, knowledge and business studies too to name a few. Mr. Ratan Tata continues to live like an Ocean, and every drop from this Ocean is a day you wish to steal.

Mr. Ratan Tata is an embodiment of Ethics, Integrity, Culture, Patriotism, Humanity, Righteousness, thoughtful human, leadership and Virtue which seems to have evolved into an Aura that touched all our lives in one way or the other. His words of wisdom shall continue to float on the internet and his legacy shall remain unscathed forever in our hearts. Hence, no TATA for Ratan Tata!

Every time he climbed the ladder of success, he gave away something to society in return for nurturing the lower community and helping them in education, health, and labour just as generously. I wonder if that was one of the mantras for a successful entrepreneur or if it was a strategy to plan newer projects to make historic entries in the book of innovative business and successful leadership, remember the Nano Car story!

In just a month, the United States will head to the polls, and the world is closely watching as the 2024 presidential race unfolds. The Republicans have once again nominated Donald Trump, while the Democrats, after President Joe Biden stepped aside due to health concerns, have officially backed Vice President Kamala Harris as their candidate. This strategic delay in Biden’s exit may have been designed to divert Republican efforts and resources, some analysts suggest, but now the race is on, and the future of the U.S. presidency hangs in the balance.

Kamala Harris’s candidacy raises important questions about her chances of success. Biden’s influence on her campaign will be significant, tying her to both his accomplishments and his shortcomings. However, she brings her own set of strengths, including her extensive political experience as a senator, prosecutor, and vice president, along with her unique identity as an Asian-American and Black woman. Yet, much like former President Obama, her “Blackness” dominates the narrative, even though her multicultural background plays a crucial role in her appeal.

The big question remains: Could Kamala Harris become the first Black female president of the United States? She faces challenges, but her diverse identity and political track record may attract voters across different demographics. However, some critics suggest her nomination is more about meeting diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) requirements than competence, which could pose hurdles. Additionally, detractors have labeled her as a "DEI hire," an accusation that might resonate with certain conservative voters.

Harris's educational background, having attended Howard University, one of the most prestigious historically Black colleges and universities (HBCUs), adds to her credentials, but it contrasts with Obama’s Harvard pedigree, leaving some to wonder if her university experience will impact her candidacy. Another challenge she faces is personal—accusations about not having biological children, despite her role as a stepmother, with some attacking her as part of a "childless cat ladies" narrative. While this seems trivial, in a country with strong conservative undercurrents, such issues could resonate with certain voters.

On policy, Harris may struggle to define herself. Critics point to her background as a prosecutor, questioning whether it will be viewed seriously or just as a punchline in Trump's campaign rhetoric. Furthermore, foreign policy could be a weak point, as Republicans are likely to hammer home critiques of the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan and other foreign policy decisions made under the Biden administration. Immigration, too, is a hot-button issue that Republicans are using to link her to unpopular decisions.

Trump, on the other hand, will be emphasizing his strong political base, nationalist appeal, and his perceived successes during his previous presidency, especially regarding the economy and his hardline stance on China. His connection to white, working-class voters remains strong, and his recent health scare and legal battles have only solidified his image as a political fighter. However, Trump’s divisive rhetoric, especially against immigrants and Muslims, is reminiscent of authoritarian tactics seen elsewhere. He continues to use inflammatory language, such as describing Democrats as radical leftists and calling for the defeat of Marxism, socialism, and communism.

If Harris wins, some argue it won’t bring a dramatic shift in U.S. policies, especially since foreign and domestic policies rarely undergo major changes when the presidency changes hands in America. However, if Trump is reelected, the consequences could be far-reaching, both for the U.S. and the world.

As the race tightens, Kamala’s choice for vice president will be critical. A strong running mate, perhaps someone like Gavin Newsom, who complements her experience and identity, could bolster her campaign. Newsom’s leadership in a solidly Democratic state would be crucial in shoring up the party’s strongholds, especially in the 18 blue wall states that Trump has been targeting.

The outcome of this election will have significant implications beyond U.S. borders. Republicans and Democrats have distinct policies on trade, foreign investment, and immigration, all of which will affect relations with countries like India and African nations. As Trump and Harris both gear up for their campaigns, the world is watching closely. The possibility of the first Black, Asian, and female president in U.S. history is tantalizing, but her path to victory is far from certain.

Ultimately, the outcome of this election will shape not only America’s future but also the global landscape. The world waits to see if the U.S. is ready to embrace this historic moment.

Former Law Minister Hansraj Bhardwaj played a transformative role in reshaping India’s legal landscape, significantly improving the lives of judges, lawyers, and the common people seeking justice. His tenure saw a series of reforms that uplifted the judiciary’s working conditions and brought long-overdue changes to the legal profession. Bhardwaj’s vision was not only to modernize the system but also to make justice more accessible, particularly to the underprivileged, thereby leaving an enduring legacy.

Uplifting Judicial Pay Scales and Perks

One of the major achievements during Bhardwaj’s tenure was the introduction of better pay scales and perks for judges, ensuring they received compensation reflective of their status and responsibilities. The judiciary had long struggled with inadequate salaries, which often affected morale and recruitment. By pushing for competitive pay, Bhardwaj ensured that judges were rewarded for their important role in upholding democracy and the rule of law. The revisions in pay scales also included provisions for regular increments, making the judicial profession more attractive to qualified candidates.

Housing and Infrastructure

Bhardwaj recognized that housing and infrastructure were critical to the efficient functioning of the judiciary. He spearheaded efforts to provide judges with well-maintained, government-allocated housing. This move allowed judicial officers, particularly those stationed in remote areas, to live in comfortable conditions, reducing the stress and instability often associated with their roles. By improving the availability and quality of housing, Bhardwaj created a more stable and conducive environment for judges to focus on their work.

In addition to housing, Bhardwaj oversaw improvements in court infrastructure. New chambers for advocates, modern court buildings, and air-conditioned courtrooms were introduced to enhance the working environment. These changes were instrumental in ensuring that the legal proceedings were carried out efficiently and in a more professional setting.

Better Travel Allowances and Vehicles

Recognizing the extensive travel that many judges, especially those in rural areas, had to undertake, Bhardwaj improved travel allowances and provided vehicles for judicial officers. This initiative reduced the personal strain on judges and helped them better manage their workloads. Travel allowances for attending court proceedings and official duties were significantly enhanced, ensuring judges had access to reliable transportation, whether by road or air, for both local and long-distance travel.

Health and Life Insurance

Bhardwaj introduced comprehensive health and life insurance schemes for judges and their families, safeguarding them from the uncertainties of medical emergencies and providing them with financial security. These initiatives ensured that judges and legal professionals could focus on their work without worrying about health expenses. Life insurance, too, was a critical addition, offering security to families of those serving in the judiciary.

Digitization and E-Library

A visionary in embracing technology, Bhardwaj championed the digitization of court records, ensuring the legal system moved toward a more efficient, transparent, and accessible future. By implementing electronic record-keeping, he eliminated delays associated with physical documents and made the retrieval of case files faster and easier. Digitization also played a crucial role in improving case management and streamlining the flow of information.

The introduction of e-libraries was another key reform. These libraries provided judges, lawyers, and law students access to a vast array of legal literature, judgments, and case laws online. The shift to digital resources revolutionized research, enabling faster and more comprehensive legal analysis.

Lok Adalats and Speedy Justice

Bhardwaj’s reforms were not just aimed at improving the lives of judges and lawyers but also at addressing the needs of ordinary citizens. He strongly advocated for the expansion of Lok Adalats, or people’s courts, which provided speedy justice to the poor and marginalized. Lok Adalats became an essential tool in reducing the backlog of cases, offering an alternative dispute resolution mechanism that was both cost-effective and timely. Bhardwaj’s focus on the efficient dispensation of justice, especially for those who could not afford long-drawn legal battles, reflected his commitment to making the legal system more inclusive.

Conclusion

Hansraj Bhardwaj’s tenure as Law Minister marked a watershed moment in India’s judicial history. Through reforms in pay, housing, infrastructure, healthcare, and digitization, he not only improved the quality of life for judges and legal professionals but also enhanced the overall efficiency of the judicial system. His emphasis on Lok Adalats ensured that justice was not a privilege reserved for the few but a right available to all, especially the underprivileged. His legacy continues to influence the Indian legal system, promoting a more equitable and modern judiciary

India’s first Prime Minister Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru once remarked, “Events crowd in upon us in such quick succession that we are apt to miss their true significance.” The American Vice President Kamala Devi Harris is forging ahead of former President Donald John Trump by leaps and bounds in the upcoming US Presidential Elections in all but one of the dozen different polls tracked by the polling aggregator 538 (originally rendered as FiveThirtyEight) after their effervescent Presidential Debate on 10th September 2024 in Philadelphia (colloquially referred to as “Philly”), the birthplace of American Independence famous for The State House Bell, now known as the Liberty Bell, which is at once recognizable by its discernible crack and bears the timeless message: “Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants thereof”. 538 gives Trump only a slender 39% chance of winning the electoral college while boosting Kamala’s odds to a clinching 61%! The Presidential Debate was a watershed moment for Kamala enabling her to steer confidently towards the Gettysburg ideal of “government of the people, by the people, for the people”. From the moment Kamala ascended onto the stage at the National Constitution Center and firmly shook Trump’s hand with amazing aplomb and élan to introduce herself, she displayed her unmistakable “I-am-in-command” credentials. It was an astute and pace-setting opening move! Since the two had never met before, her decision to shake his hand imbued her with astonishing maturity and gumption. Michael Richard Beschloss, the charismatic NBC News Presidential Historian and author of nine books, declared that Kamala had “delivered what is easily one of the most successful debate performances in all of American history”. On 21st September 2024, Kamala challenged Trump to another debate in the lead-up to the election and revealed that she had accepted a debate invitation from Cable News Network (“CNN”) on 23rd October 2024. Three other influential American poll pundits viz. Allan Lichtman (known as the “Nostradamus” of US presidential elections), Nate Silver and Alan Abramowitz have predicted Kamala’s victory. Significantly, Kamala has received full and unequivocal star power and celebrity endorsement throughout the length and breadth of Uncle Sam’s land. Mary Louise “Meryl” Streep, Jennifer Lynn Affleck (nee Lopez), popularly known as “J.Lo”, and Julia Fiona Roberts were among the celebrities who pitched for Kamala in a breezy online 90 minutes star-studded event hosted by Oprah Winfrey on 19th September 2024 on CBS News in Farmington Hills, Michigan, zeroing in on women’s reproductive rights that touched the innermost chords of voters from the fairer sex in the United States. And not to be outdone, Jane Seymour Fonda, Taylor Alison Swift and George Timothy Clooney are triggering the Kamala swing with impassioned gusto in the greatest republic, the greatest democracy and the greatest nation under the sun!

The name “Kamala” is a majestic name stemming from the ancient Sanskrit word meaning “lotus flower”. The lotus (botanical name “Nelumbo nucifera”) is a flower permeated with an enormous wealth of spiritual symbolism, inextricably linked to Hinduism and Buddhism.  In Christianity, the lotus is associated with Thomas the Apostle and his twenty-year-old presence in India. He is regarded as the Patron Saint of India among its Christian adherents and the Feast of Saint Thomas on 3rd July is reverentially celebrated as Indian Christian Day. This is because he was brutally assassinated with a spear at St. Thomas Mount (previously Mylapore, the hallowed birthplace of the celebrated Tamil philosopher Valluvar and the Hindu saint and philosopher Peyalvar) in Chennai on 3rd July in AD 72 and his mortal remains were finally interred in the magnificent 1523 Portugese built Roman Catholic church St.Thomas Cathedral Basilca. I have visited St.Thomas Mount several times where the sculptured statue of Christ the King on the cross inside the St.Thomas Cathedral Basilca is flanked by two peacocks with his feet proudly resting on a lotus. The lotus is also mentioned in Job 40:21-22  in the Holy Bible: “Under the lotus plants it lies, hidden among the reeds in the marsh. The lotuses conceal it in their shadow; the poplars by the stream surround it.” Each religion lends a slightly varied touch, but the lotus invariably reflects spiritual awakening, purity, rebirth, creation and eternity. Fully grounded in the earth, the lotus heeds the call of the sun each morning, breaks the surface of the water and blooms untouched by the mud; each petal remains clean and pure. Closing at night, it sinks below the water’s surface, only to resurface again in the morning. Lord Gautam Buddha aptly observed, “As the lotus rises on its stalk unsoiled by the mud and water, so the wise one speaks of peace and is unstained by the opinions of the world.” And here I am irresistibly drawn to the inimitable Washington born American actress Goldie Jeanne Hawn who received the Academy Award and Golden Globe Award for Best Supporting Actress for her stellar performance in Cactus Flower in 1969. Even though Hawn’s mother Laura (née Steinhoff) was the daughter of Jewish immigrants from Hungary and she was brought up as a Jewish girl, Hawn became deeply involved in Buddhist philosophy way back in 1972 and is today a practising Buddhist and proudly claims, “Buddhism is my religion and Judaism is my tribe.” Notably, in her well-known memoir entitled “A Lotus Grows in the Mud” co-authored in 2005 with the renowned British novelist Wendy Holden, she reverberated the thoughts of Buddha, “The lotus is the most beautiful flower, whose petals open one by one. But it will only grow in the mud. To grow and gain wisdom, first, you must have the mud — the obstacles of life and its suffering…The mud speaks of the common ground that humans share, no matter what our stations in life… Whether we have it all or we have nothing, we are all faced with the same obstacles: sadness, loss, illness, dying and death. If we are to strive as human beings to gain more wisdom, more kindness and more compassion, we must have the intention to grow as a lotus and open each petal one by one.” Before taking leave of Buddhism and its association with the lotus, I am highly emboldened to advert to you the incredible story of the fabulous mystic, master scholar and outrageous yogi Padmasambhava, the Lotus-Born, who was miraculously born from within a lotus with a thousand petals in the middle of a lake in the land of Oddiyana, having been sent as a meteor from the heart of the “Buddha of Boundless Light” and went on to live for more than five hundred years.  He is also known as “Guru Rinpoche” or “Precious Master” and is revered by Tibetans as the real founder of Buddhism in Tibet who subjugated demons, transformed a huge fire into the lotus-shaped Rewalsar Lake (also known as  “Tso Pema”) located in the mountains of the Mandi district in Himachal Pradesh and spread Buddha’s message far and wide with a missionary zeal. Harris is a name of diverse origins across the globe. The name is traditionally patronymic as it’s often tied to Harrison, meaning “son of Harry”. It was most popularly used as a surname in England and Wales in the days of yore. Harris has seeds in the names Harry and Henry, meaning “home ruler” in both German and Old English. Harris is also a variant of the Scandinavian name Harold, meaning “army ruler.” Harrisburg (named after the 17th century Yorkshire-born American businessman John Harris Sr who landed in Philadelphia with just sixteen guineas [equivalent to four ounces of gold] in his pocket!), situated on the east bank of the Susquehanna River, is the capital city of the U.S. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and the seat of Dauphin County. Harrison City is situated in Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania. Significantly, William Henry Harrison was the ninth and shortest serving President of the United States, as he was the first President to die in harness. His grandson Benjamin Harrison was the 23rd President of the United States.

Kamala was born on 20th October 1964 at 9.28 pm at Kaiser Permanente Oakland Medical Center in Oakland, California. And here it would not be out of place to mention that the popular 28-year-old Oakland-born 5’10’’ tall chocolate-addicted actress and singer Zendaya Maree Stoermer Coleman effusively remarked in the Dec 2015/Jan 2016 issue of the New York-based fashion and entertainment bi-monthly magazine COMPLEX, “Oakland kids are always the best”! Kamala’s Chennai-born and bred mother, Shyamala Gopalan, was a biologist who arrived in the United States from India in 1958 at the tender age of 19 to enroll in graduate school in endocrinology at the University of California ("UC"), Berkeley. An intensive research career of over 40 years ensued, during which her work on the progesterone receptor gene led to pioneering advances in breast cancer treatment. Kamala’s Jamaican-African father Donald Jasper Harris arrived in the United States from Jamaica in 1961 on an Elias A. Issa Scholarship (founded and funded by the House of Issa at the behest of the Kingston merchant Elias A. Issa in 1938) and enrolled in UC Berkeley to specialize in development economics. The first Afro-American scholar to be granted tenure at the Department of Economics at Stanford University, he now enjoys the coveted emeritus status there. The Stanford Daily in November 1976 described Harris as a Marxist scholar the university viewed as “too charismatic, a pied piper leading students astray from neo-classical economics”. Kamala’s parents met in the fall of 1962 at a meeting of the Afro-American Association at UC, Berkeley, and got married on 5th July 1963 without following the convention of introducing Harris to Shyamala’s parents beforehand or having the ceremony in her native place. The couple had another daughter Maya Lakshmi Harris who was born in Champaign-Urbana, Illinois, on 30th January, 1967. Maya is today a versatile lawyer, public policy advocate and writer. Kamala’s marriage to Dough foundered and the couple separated and were officially divorced in 1972. Shyamala won custody of the two children a year later. Thereafter, the children were raised largely by their mother but saw their father only on weekends. While growing up, Kamala maintained close contact with her Indian family and frequently traveled with her mother and sister to Chennai. In her 2019 memoir “The Truths We Hold: An American Journey” Kamala wrote, “My mother, grandparents, aunts and uncle instilled us with pride in our South Asian roots. Our classical Indian names harked back to our heritage, and we were raised with a strong awareness of and appreciation for Indian culture.” At the same time, she wrote about her mother, “She knew that her adopted homeland would see Maya and me as Black girls, and she was determined to make sure we would grow into confident, proud Black women.” She also had a word of praise for her father whom she described as a “brilliant student”. And at the Democratic National Convention, she recalled with a sense of helpless nostalgia, “At the park, my mother would say, ‘Stay close.’ But my father would say, as he smiled, ‘Run, Kamala, run. Don’t be afraid. Don’t let anything stop you.’ From my earliest years, he taught me to be fearless.” Kamala studied political science and economics at Howard University, a historically Black college. While there, she pledged to the Alpha Kappa Alpha sorority, one of the “Divine Nine” sororities and fraternities founded by Black students. She was also on the debating team and was elected to the student council. After graduating from Howard in 1986, Kamala earned a law degree from the University of California College of the Law, San Francisco (formerly known as Hastings College) in 1989.

After gaining a law degree, Harris worked as a deputy district attorney in the city of her birth Oakland from 1990-98, earning a reputation for solidity as she prosecuted cases of gang violence, drug trafficking, sexual abuse, homicide and robbery. In March 1994, San Francisco Chronicle’s legendary columnist Herb Caen described the scene at former San Francisco Speaker and Mayor Willie Lewis Brown’s surprise 60th birthday party. Brown had a penchant for dating much younger women. The celebrated Hollywood actor Clint Eastwood Jr. (who served for two years as the Mayor of Carmel-by-the-Sea, California!), was there, wrote Caen, and he “spilled champagne on the Speaker’s new steady, Kamala Harris.” In his column, Caen described Kamala as “something new in Willie’s love life. She’s a woman, not a girl.” The relationship (which Kamala described later as “an albatross hanging around my neck”) ended in smoke after two years, but her connection to Brown, three decades her senior, did have a tremendous effect on her career and helped boost her connections across San Francisco high-society and California political elite. In 1998, Kamala was named Managing Attorney of the Career Criminal Unit of the San Francisco District Attorney’s Office where she prosecuted three strike cases and serial felony offenders. She then served as the head of the San Francisco City Attorney’s Division on Families and Children. She rose determinedly through the ranks, becoming the first African American and South Asian American woman  District Attorney in 2004 in San Francisco’s history, a post she held with distinction till 2010. Kamala’s mother Shyamala died of colon cancer in Oakland on 11th February, 2009, at the age of 70. Later in 2009, Kamala carried her mother’s ashes to Chennai and one one sunny morning walked down with her uncle to the beach in Besant Nagar where she used to stroll with her grandfather as a child and scattered the ashes on the waves. As a trailblazer throughout her entire life and career, Kamala was deeply attached to her mother and never fails to talk about the lessons she learned from her mother in glowing terms. In a Facebook post on 8th May 2022, on the occasion of Mother’s Day, 2022, she recalled, “My mother would often say to me: ‘Kamala, you may be the first to do many things. Make sure you are not the last'. This instantly brings to my mind the immortal words of Abraham “Abe” Lincoln, the towering sixteenth President of the United States who is universally hailed as the father of modern democracy (about whom Philip Henry Kerr, 11th Marquess of Lothian [one time British Ambassador to the United States], in a letter to Nehru written on New Year's Eve, 1935, wrote, “I think that the greatest political figure that the democratic world has thrown up is Abraham Lincoln”) - “The greatest lessons I have ever learned were at my mother's knees... All that I am, or hope to be, I owe to my angel mother.” and “I remember my mother's prayers and they have always followed me. They have clung to me all my life.” Kamala’s best-selling book  “Smart on Crime” was co-written with the well-known California-based writing collaborator and content consultant Joan O’C. Hamilton in 2009 was considered a model for dealing with the problem of criminal recidivism. In 2010, she succeeded Edmund Gerald “Jerry” Brown Jr. as California’s attorney general, becoming the first female, Black and South Asian attorney general to be catapulted to that office. After taking office in 2011, she demonstrated political sagacity. One of Kamala’s crowning accomplishments as attorney general came in 2012 when she, along with 40 other attorney generals, reached a multi-billion dollar deal (five times higher than that originally offered which she rejected as “crumbs on the table” despite pressure from the administration of President Barack Obama!) with five U.S. banks that settled over flawed mortgage foreclosure practices. The deal provided relief to those affected by those unfair practices, with the average eligible homeowner receiving $20,000 in mortgage aid. Her refusal to defend Proposition 8 (2008), which banned same-sex marriage in California, helped lead to its being overturned in 2013. Though Kamala had personally opposed the death penalty earlier in her career, she announced in 2014 that she would appeal a federal court ruling that declared it unconstitutional because delays in capital punishment in the state rendered it cruel and unusual. Years later, as a senator and during her 2020 run for President, Kamala pushed for a federal moratorium on the death penalty after California Governor Gavin Christopher Newsom signed an executive order halting executions in the state. In 2012, Kamala delivered a memorable address at the Democratic National Convention, elevating her national profile to dizzy heights. On 22nd August 2014, she tied the knot with Douglas “Doug” Craig Emhoff, a New York-born Jewish-American entertainment lawyer (who is presently a partner at the global law firm DLA Piper), at the iconic Santa Barbara County Courthouse (the jaw-dropping, gorgeous example of Spanish Colonial Revival architecture marked by its distinctive four-faced clock tower!) at a small and intimate ceremony presided over by Maya…Doug wore a garland as a nod to Kamala’s Hindu roots and she broke a glass to honour his Jewish heritage! Interestingly, the two first met in 2013 on a blind date set up by a mutual friend Chrisette Hudlin (now the wife of the noted Afro-American Hollywood director-producer Reginald Alan Hudlin), a public relations consultant, in Los Angeles. They now have a wonderful blended family embellished by their two “brilliant, talented, funny kids” Ella and Cole (brought into this world by Dough’s first film producer wife Kerstin Mackin)…named after two Afro-American celebrities viz. John William Coltrane, the phenomenal Jazz saxophonist and band leader, and Ella Jane Fitzgerald, the monumental singer, songwriter and composer known the world over as the “First Lady of Song” and “Queen of Jazz”! Widely feted as a rising star within the party, Kamala was roped in to run for the US Senate seat held by Barbara Sue Boxer, who was on the verge of hanging up her gloves. In early 2015, Kamala declared her candidacy, and on the campaign trail, she doggedly battled for immigration and criminal justice reform, an increase in the minimum wage and protection of women’s reproductive rights.

Kamala joined the US Senate after being elected in 2016 and a new chapter in her checkered career unfolded. When she took office in January 2017, Kamala became the first Indian American and only the second Black American woman in the Senate; the first being Carol Moseley Braun. She joined the Congressional Black Caucus as well as the Congressional Asian-Pacific American Caucus. She also began serving on both the Select Committee on Intelligence and the Judiciary Committee, among other assignments. She became known for her prosecutorial style of addressing witnesses during hearings. In June, she drew particular attention for her questioning of U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions, who was testifying before the intelligence committee on alleged Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election, after she had publicly called on him to hang up his boots. In 2016, Kamala was one of 17 attorney generals to reinforce efforts to fight climate change by addressing power plant greenhouse gas emissions. She joined a coalition led by New York Attorney General Eric Tradd Schneiderman to investigate whether fossil fuel companies had misled the public on the true impact of climate change. A year earlier, she defended President Obama's Clean Power Plan, which aimed to reduce emissions by 2030. She also supported the Environmental Protection Agency’s standards to limit gas emissions from oil and natural gas operations. During her tenure as attorney general, she reached several settlements with oil companies over alleged violations of state laws. In 2011, she announced a $24.5 million settlement with Chevron over allegations that it violated state hazardous materials and waste laws. Kamala later settled with BP West Coast in 2016 for alleged violations of state laws governing the operation and maintenance of underground gasoline tanks. In 2016, her office obtained a landmark $1.1 billion judgment against Corinthian Colleges, a chain based in Southern California.

In January 2019, Kamala published her memoir  “The Truths We Hold: An American Journey”. Shortly thereafter, Kamala announced that she was seeking the Democratic presidential nomination in 2020. From the word go, she was seen as one of the leading contenders, and she gained attention when, during a primary debate, she had a contentious exchange with fellow candidate Joseph “Joe” Robinette Biden Jr. over his opposition to school busing in the 1970s and ’80s, among other race-related topics. By September 2019, her campaign was in dire straits and in December she voluntarily dropped out of the race. She continued to maintain a high profile, notably becoming a leading advocate for social justice reform following the death of George Perry Floyd Jr, an African American who was murdered on 25th May 2020 by a white police officer Derek Michael Chauvin in Minneapolis, Minnesota, during an arrest made after a Cup Foods grocery store clerk suspected Floyd of having used a counterfeit twenty-dollar bill. Her valiant efforts muzzled all her detractors who had questioned her tenure as attorney general, alleging that she had failed to investigate charges of police misconduct, including questionable shootings. As racial injustice emerged as a major issue in the United States, many Democrats emphatically mulled the idea of Biden choosing an African American as his vice presidential running mate. In August, Biden chose Kamala and she thus became the first Black woman to appear on a major party’s national ticket. On 20th January 2021, Kamala was sworn in as Vice President – the first woman, the first Black American and the first South Asian American to be elected to this position. After she was elected Vice President, Kamala thanked her mother, crediting her with her success in her victory speech in a voice choked with visible emotion, “To the woman most responsible for my presence here today, my mother, Shyamala Gopalan Harris, who is always in our hearts…When she came here from India at the age of 19, she maybe didn't quite imagine this moment, but she believed so deeply in an America where a moment like this is possible.”

On 23rd June 2023, Kamala hosted a grand State Luncheon in honour of the visiting Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the Harry S. Truman Building in Washington, D.C. In her welcome speech, Kamala said, “And around our country, we see the impact of Indian Americans, from the C suites of American companies to neighborhood businesses, from the studios of Hollywood to university research labs across our country. So, as many of you know, India is a very important part of my life.  When my sister Maya and I were growing up, our mother would take us from the Bay Area to India pretty much every other year. And the purpose of those trips were many, including that we would well understand where she came from, what produced her; so that we could spend time with our grandparents, with my uncle and our chittis; and to understand the love of good idli. And we traveled to visit my grandparents in what was then called Madras. And I will tell you, my grandfather was one of the most favorite people in my life, truly..on those visits, I was the only member of our family that my grandfather allowed to join him for his morning routine…Throughout these walks, I recall my grandfather teaching me lessons about not just what it means to have a democracy but to keep a democracy. And I do believe it is these lessons that I learned at a very young age that first inspired my interest in public service... In fact, it is a large part of who I am today — these lessons I learned from my grandfather, P.V. Gopalan, and the dedication, determination, and courage of his daughter, my mother, Shyamala.  And it is the reason that I stand before you today as vice president of the United States. The history and teachings in India and of India have not only influenced me, but they, of course, have shaped the entire globe…Throughout history, India has inspired millions of people around the world, whether through philosophy and theology, the power of civil disobedience, or the commitment to democracy…As we look toward the future, the United States and India, the world’s oldest and largest democracies, instinctively turn to each other and are increasingly aligned.” It is indeed a happy coincidence that Modi is right now firmly ensconced on American soil on an action pact visit and has already participated in the fourth Quad Leaders Summit in Biden’s hometown Wilmington in Delaware, which was also attended by Kamala. Modi and Kamala are bound to have had a tête-à-tête on the sidelines of the Summit or otherwise!

As Biden’s Vice President, Kamala was tasked with addressing the root causes of increased migration from Latin America to the American southern border, promoting national legislation to protect voting rights and preserving women’s access to abortion, which was significantly stifled in many states following the 2022 controversial ruling in Dobbs vs.Jackson Women’s Health Organization in which the US Supreme Court held that the Constitution of the United States did not confer the right to abortion. Kamala became a vocal and effective crusader for the right to complete reproductive health care, including abortion, and continued that theme as part of Biden’s 2024 campaign. As President of the Senate, Kamala cast the most tie-breaking votes in history, shattering a nearly 200-year-old record. On 21st July 21, 2024, Biden unilaterally suspended his campaign for re-election in 2024 and endorsed Kamala for President. Kamala was endorsed by Jimmy Earl Carter, William Jefferson, Bill Clinton, Hillary Diane Rodham Clinton, Obama and Michelle LaVaughn Robinson Obama, the Congressional Black Caucus, and many other leading Democrats. In the first 24 hours of her candidacy, her campaign raised $81 million in small-dollar donations, the highest single-day total of any presidential candidate in American history. By 5th August 2024, Kamala had officially secured the nomination via a virtual roll call of delegates. The next day, she announced Minnesota Governor Tim James Walz as her vice presidential running mate. On 22nd August 2024, the fourth day of the Democratic National Convention, Kamala officially accepted the Democratic nomination for president and her acceptance was certified by the Democratic National Committee. She thus became the first Black woman and the first Asian American in U.S. history to win the presidential nomination of a major party.

I do not possess a crystal ball, but I'm willing to bet one of my arms right now that Kamala is the most clearly positioned heir to the White House. The eyes of the world are upon Kamala intently watching this Afro-American Vice President (through whose veins the sacred blood of India flows in abundant measure!) as she braces herself for the most challenging Presidential trial of strength that lies ahead of her…indomitable, unflinching, unswerving and relentless! Victory shall be hers and her victory shall be the victory of every single woman on earth! God bless Kamala! God bless America!

A BRIEF NOTE ON THE AUTHOR

The author is an internationally reputed senior lawyer practising in the Supreme Court of India and various High Courts and Tribunals in India. He has been closely associated with some of the topmost Indian corporates as a lawyer and advisor. He addressed a select gathering of MPs and other eminent persons in the House of Lords in February 2009 and was awarded the prestigious “Ambassador of Peace Award”. In April 2009, he was also invited to the House of  Commons. He was also invited by Chatham House and by the Universal Peace Federation in London several times. He is an avid debater, public speaker, writer, broadcaster, telecaster, artist, painter, sculptor, music critic and filmmaker. 

September 18, 2024: Renowned for setting new benchmarks in management education since its inception in 2001, the Indian School of Business (ISB), is poised to embark on another groundbreaking path in its mission to groom future leaders for India and the world.  ISB has announced the launch of PGP YL - a 20 month Post Graduate Programme in Management for Young Leaders (PGP YL), a full time MBA equivalent residential management programme for high-potential aspirants with up to 2 years of full-time work experience.

Commencing in mid 2025, ISB’s PGP YL will offer a comprehensive learning experience through an innovative and cutting-edge curriculum designed as a response to the rapidly evolving business landscape and technology disruptions. The research backed PGP YL curriculum will blend foundational business principles with advanced technology, data, analytics courses and global perspectives to develop students into innovative problem solvers.

Given the students' limited work experience, the PGP YL curriculum has been designed to incorporate significant experiential learning components, including a Business Design Lab and an Innovation Lab. Additionally, students will be required to complete a mandatory two-month summer internship, which will provide them with practical exposure to business environments in various settings. Students in the PGP YL programme will be taught by renowned faculty from ISB and other top international B-schools who will bring their expertise to the classroom.  

Speaking about the new PGP YL programme, Professor Madan Pillutla, Dean, ISB, said, “Since our inception in 2001, ISB has been imparting world-class management education to create leaders for India and the world. Our many conversations with industry leaders and recruiters reveal a need for young professionals who can step straight into roles that require business acumen alongside deep expertise in data and technology. In line with these requirements, we have designed the PGP YL programme for fresh graduates and entry level professionals to transform them into exceptional problem solvers and innovators at the workplace.”

Students interested in applying for the PGP YL programme will have to submit a valid GMAT, GRE or CAT score, in addition to the details of their educational qualifications and work experience, if any. The admissions process for the PGP YL programme includes a personal interview based on the students’ academic excellence, application essays and test score performance. The shortlisted students will then be interviewed by a panel consisting of leading industry practitioners, academicians, and ISB alumni in senior positions.

The programme fee for the academic year 2025-27 is INR 21,65,000 + GST and the accommodation fee is INR 3,95,000. Scholarships will be awarded to 40-50% of the class based on merit and merit-cum-need criteria. Merit scholarships may offer up to a 100% tuition waiver for deserving candidates.

For further information, please log on to https://www.isb.edu/en/study-isb/post-graduate-programmes/pgpyl.html

About Indian School of Business (ISB)

The Indian School of Business (ISB) is India’s highest-ranked business school and ranks in the top league of business schools in several rankings globally. A vibrant pool of research-oriented resident faculty, robust academic partnerships, a thriving alumni network, the backing of an influential board, and guidance of the industry’s thought leadership have enabled ISB to fast emerge and consolidate itself as a premier global business school in emerging markets.

Media contacts:

Vasudha D. Rao, Indian School of Business                                            Priya Soni, Genesis BCW

Vasudha_Rao@isb.edu                                                                                  Priya.Soni@genesis-bcw.com

Mobile No.: 98203 47118                                                                            Mobile No.: 70422 20292

Congress leader Rahul Gandhi has reportedly been advised by international agencies to align with the National Conference ahead of the Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) assembly elections. This partnership is seen as a way to frame their joint victory as more than a regional outcome. Regardless of the specific winner, regional pro-Islamist political parties are expected to secure a collective victory in the elections. Notably, Pakistan is unlikely to interfere with the process, as it is essential for the global conspiracy against India and Prime Minister Narendra Modi that the elections appear legitimate through significant popular participation.

Once elected, the J&K assembly is expected to immediately challenge the Indian government’s 2019 decision to rescind Articles 370 and 35A. The political parties projected to win the elections have promised to repudiate this move. They will likely contest the 2019 rescinding as unconstitutional, arguing that it did not have the consent of the J&K Assembly—a point that former Foreign Secretary Shyam Saran and others have suggested was constitutionally envisaged.

This move could precipitate a national crisis, as the issue is expected to reach India's Supreme Court. Narendra Modi’s government cannot accept such a challenge to the nation’s constitutional integrity, especially given the practical consequences of the 2019 rescinding, which has already been ratified by Parliament and the Supreme Court. The government will face intense pressure, as any repudiation of the articles by the J&K assembly would present a severe threat to India’s political credibility.

However, concerns have been raised that the Supreme Court may not address this issue swiftly, potentially allowing the crisis to escalate. The Court could deprive the J&K assembly’s actions of legal validity by denouncing its resolution, but there is speculation that it may instead delay the matter, allowing political tensions to grow. Interestingly, the Chief Justice of India has pushed for the elections to be held by September, reportedly threatening the Election Commission with contempt of court if the elections are delayed.
Should the Modi government take no action in response to the unfolding crisis, its authority could be significantly undermined, and the legitimacy of the Delhi government may suffer as the newly elected J&K assembly moves forward with its challenge to the 2019 decision.

This could set the stage for a broader political crisis, with national protests erupting against any firm measures taken by the government. Some observers believe this could paralyze the country, combined with a potential Khalistani uprising in Delhi, which is allegedly being prepared openly. This destabilization might also include bombings and train derailments, adding to the national turmoil.

At this critical juncture, key NDA allies like Nitish Kumar and Chandrababu Naidu could threaten to withdraw their support unless Narendra Modi resigns, aiming to defuse the crisis. Such a resignation would pave the way for Articles 370 and 35A to be restored through new parliamentary legislation, with the blame for the preceding chaos being placed squarely on Modi’s 2019 actions.

Global media, in turn, would likely amplify calls for regime change. For Modi, resigning and allowing the NDA to continue without him might be preferable to seeing the coalition collapse entirely. His departure would offer some personal security issues, as there may be no safe haven abroad. Ultimately, Modi's resignation would halt India’s rise as a global player, with many of his domestic and international adversaries prioritizing his political downfall over the country’s future trajectory.

The recent visit by Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the residence of Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud, which was followed by a video of a private prayer being circulated on social media, raises questions about the ethical boundaries that must be maintained between the judiciary and the executive. While the Modi government has made significant strides in areas such as digital infrastructure, national security, and anti-corruption measures, this particular incident reflects a disturbing trend of breaking conventions and undermining institutions that form the bedrock of democracy.

The circulation of a video from the CJI's private residence, especially one depicting a personal religious ceremony, is an unprecedented violation of an individual's right to privacy. In a country where the judiciary is seen as a cornerstone of democracy, any intrusion into the personal life of the Chief Justice is not just unwarranted but potentially harmful. Private religious or family gatherings should remain personal, not fodder for public consumption, especially when they are used to fuel political narratives.

For Prime Minister Modi to attend a private function at the residence of the Chief Justice is one thing. But to turn that private event into a public spectacle by allowing videos to be made and then amplifying them on social media sets a dangerous precedent. It brings the judiciary into the public eye in ways that could undermine its impartiality, demoralize its members, and create an environment where judicial independence is questioned.

One of the hallmarks of a functioning democracy is the separation of powers. The executive, judiciary, and legislature must operate independently, and their leaders should uphold a clear boundary between personal interactions and institutional relationships. By visiting the CJI’s house and making the event a matter of public discourse, the prime minister may have breached these boundaries, contributing to the politicization of an institution that must remain apolitical and impartial to safeguard justice.

Modi's action, deliberate or not, sends a troubling message about the relationship between the executive and judiciary. It risks creating a perception that the judiciary, particularly its top leader, can be influenced, scrutinized, or even targeted in subtle ways. This is not just a matter of invading the privacy of an individual; it is an infringement on the sanctity of an institution.

Modi's government has been known for breaking conventions and long-standing traditions, often under the guise of modernizing or streamlining governance. While this has, in some cases, led to positive changes—such as promoting digital infrastructure, boosting the morale of the defense forces, and improving India’s global image—it has also led to worrying trends in other areas.

Crony capitalism, for example, has flourished under Modi’s rule. While his government has effectively tackled corruption at various levels, there have been accusations of favoring large industrialists and business houses close to the government. This imbalance has raised concerns about the growing influence of a few corporate players in shaping policy decisions that should ideally serve the wider public interest.

Similarly, the Modi government’s centralized decision-making process has sidelined other democratic institutions, with Parliament being frequently bypassed for ordinances and an increasing concentration of power in the hands of the executive. The judiciary, in particular, has faced numerous challenges, including delayed appointments and political pressure, leading to a perception that its independence is being eroded.

While Modi’s tenure has witnessed significant advancements in various sectors, his repeated tendency to break conventions and put personal or political interests ahead of institutional integrity poses a serious threat to India’s democratic framework. The very institutions that have safeguarded the country for decades—the judiciary, Parliament, the Election Commission—are being strained under the weight of centralized, personality-driven governance.

The CJI incident is just the latest example of this. Instead of fostering respect for institutional boundaries, the prime minister's actions reflect a tendency to blur the lines between personal, political, and institutional roles, often to the detriment of the very systems he claims to uphold.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s leadership has been marked by a combination of undeniable successes and worrying missteps. His government has contributed to national security, economic development, technological progress, historic digitalization, and major leaps in space science. But his repeated disregard for conventions threatens to weaken India’s institutional framework. The recent episode involving CJI Chandrachud’s private ceremony being made public is emblematic of this troubling trend. India’s democracy relies on the strength of its institutions, and any attempt to infringe upon their autonomy for political gain must be recognized and resisted.